Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters for Framingham-Area Homeowners

Water Heaters vs. Tankless Water Heaters Is your water heater dead or on it’s last leg? You’re not alone. About 27 million U.S. homeowners have a water heater that’s over 10 years old. That’s the typical life expectancy of a traditional tank water heater.

While searching for a new water heater, you’ve come across tankless water heaters (also called on-demand water heaters). On-demand hot water sounds promising. But you’re wondering if it’s worth switching to.

Fear not! We’ll help you out.

In this article, we’ll compare tankless and tank water heaters on these important factors:

  • Price and installation costs
  • Energy efficiency (aka, how do they affect your energy bills)
  • Hot water provided
  • Life expectancy
  • Space requirements

Price and installation costs

On average, a tankless water heater will cost about 2 to 3 times as much as a tank water heater to purchase and install.

Winner: Tank water heaters

Energy efficiency

Tank: Traditional water heaters have to keep the water they store at a constant temperature. This causes your energy bill to go up as the weather gets colder. Considering that Massachusetts’ winters can get into the single digits, this isn’t a factor you can afford to ignore.

Tankless: Tankless water heaters don’t store water (they heat it on demand). So you don’t waste energy due to standby heat loss. A typical family can save $100 or more per year with an ENERGY STAR qualified tankless water heater, according to Energy.gov.

Winner: Tankless water heaters

Hot water provided

Tank: Limited. The tank can only hold so much water. Once it’s gone, it has to refill and reheat more water.

Tankless: Endless. But the flow rate is limited (2-3 gallons of hot water per minute). So heavy multiple uses of hot water will stretch the tankless water heater to its limits.

Winner: Tankless water heaters if you don’t often use several hot water appliances at once. Tank water heaters if you do.

Life expectancy

Tank: 10-15 years

Tankless: 20+ years

Winner: Tankless water heaters

Space requirements

Tank: High. The larger the tank size, the more room you need.

Tankless: Low. Tankless water heaters can be installed almost anywhere—even under sinks!

Winner: Tankless water heaters

And the winner is…

While traditional water heaters are less expensive to install, tankless water heaters beat them out in just about every other category.

So which one is the ultimate winner?

The one that’s right for you.

Some Framingham-area homeowners can’t afford a tankless water heater because of the high initial cost. But if you can afford it, answer these questions

  • Do you run out of hot water often?
  • Do you wish you had more hot water on demand?
  • Do you want lower energy bills (especially during the harsh Minnesota winters)? If you answered yes to these then tankless is your best bet.

If you answered no to most of these, then you should replace your water heater with the traditional tank water heater.

You also need to keep in mind how long you’ll be at your home. Tankless water heaters can pay for themselves. But they need a lot of time to do that. So if you’re only going to be at your home for 10 years or less, consider getting a tank water heater instead.

Need help deciding? Contact us online for help and free estimates.

Nicholson Heating, Air Conditioning and Plumbing gladly serves the Framingham-area. Contact us online to learn more about our services.

Our level of commitment to our customer and superior service is the reason you can find comfort in choosing Nicholson Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning.

Book Online

We Take Pride in Our Work

Read about all the great things our customers have to say about us!
  • Francis from Nicholson Plumbing and Heating was excellent. He was here to evaluate HVAC in our home. He was very patient and answered all my questions. He is also polite and easy to communicate with him. He explained technical concepts to me in layperson terms!

    - Shelley S.

  • Nicholson offered what is possibly the best customer service I have dealt with in a home repair situation.  I called them because I was looking to replace my very old furnace.  They came out to do an initial estimate, and then came back when I had some further questions about my options.  After installing the furnace, they ran into some problems with my air ducts.  This happened on a Friday, and the problem was fixed by Monday afternoon.  In addition to their excellent service, they did quality work at a fair price.  I would recommend them to anyone looking for an HVAC company in the Framingham area!

    - Melissa T.

  • Recently used these guys because my HVAC unit AC wasn’t working (first hot day of summer).  Showed up on time, wore booties, fixed the unit.  During the visit we talked about how my unit was having problems in the winter – which was resulting in NSTAR service calls of maybe 3-4 times per season (I am on a service plan with them).   He was the first guy to tell me WHY the problem was happening, and HOW to fix it.  I find it strange that all of the NSTAR guys etc. no one took time to point out how to fix the source of the problem…Very professional, smart.  I would use them again, and plan to for the fix on my heating unit!

    - Ben J.

Read Our Reviews

We’re Ready to Help!

(508) 881-1500
Call Now

Our Brand Partnerships

Nicholson Plumbing, Heating and Air Conditioning is the best and most reliable source for electrical service. We are proud to be Mitsubishi Electric Diamond Elite Contractors, that have gone through extensive accreditation and training in order to provide proven high-quality service. Get in touch with us whenever you need to have electrical work done in Framingham!

Learn More